
“What do you call it when people living in the wealthiest, most powerful country on the planet report feeling worn down, burned out and on edge?”
So writes Jenifer Szalai, nonfiction book critic for the New York Times, in a review of books that “delve into our primal desire to feel valued and worthy of attention.”
Explanations for this condition, Szalai writes, include political breakdown, economic inequality and an epidemic of loneliness. But, the books suggest a crisis of “mattering” – feeling valued – a core human need that has grave consequences when it isn’t met.
For nonhuman animals, the Darwinian mechanism of gene propagation is paramount, Szalai writes. “They don’t write poetry, paint paintings or compose symphonies. Humans, though, do all sorts of strange, glorious and sometimes destructive things that are utterly superfluous (or even counter) to brute survival.”
Rebecca Newberger Goldstein, author of “The Mattering Instinct,” suggests these actions flow from our unique human longing to matter. In pursuit of mattering projects, we humans try to resist entropy because our human brains have the ability to identify it.
Goldstein maps the human mattering drive. “Socializers” want to matter to others. “Competitors” want to matter more than others. “Transcenders” want to matter to God or the universe. “Heroic Strivers” want to do something (artistic, athletic, intellectual) that matters to them.
Our mattering projects bring us a sense of purpose, Szalai writes, but references Goldstein that the longing to matter can also misdirect us and lead us astray. Also, mattering and happiness are not the same.
The publication of books on mattering “is clearly a reflection of something larger,” Szalai writes. “There is a lack, or a void, that has been ascendent in the last several years – the nihilism of ‘lol nothing matters’ and ‘I really don’t care. Do U?’ There is also the growing problem of our collapsing attention spans. All of these issues are connected.”
What matters to you? Is this the same as meaning and purpose for life? And, does it really matter?




